The More the Merrier?
Crowds and Disease Transmission
- Length: 60 Minutes
Students use powdered drink mix in plastic cups to simulate coronavirus disease transmission in different- size crowds.
- Objectives and Standards
- Materials and
- Procedure and
- Handouts and
The virus that causes COVID-19 mainly spreads through droplet transmission. These droplets are released by an infected person, whether they show symptoms or not, when that person breathes, talks, coughs, or sneezes. When one of these droplets encounters another person, that individual can become infected as well. The more people you come into contact with, the higher your chances are of contracting the virus. When transmission of the disease is high in a community, large gatherings should be avoided to lessen the chances of encountering droplets from an infected individual. Other factors that increase the risk of becoming infected at a large gathering include the duration of time spent in contact with people at the gathering, the distance between people at the gathering, not wearing masks, sharing of objects, and the number of infected persons at a gathering. It is important to remind people if they do gather to wear masks, to not share objects, to maintain a distance of at least 6 feet apart, and to limit the number of persons at the gathering.
In the model created in this activity, the powdered drink mix represents the infection—the darker the resulting color of the paper towel, the more the disease has spread. The small objects represent the number of people in attendance. This model simplifies what happens in real life, because it is not just the number of infected people at a gathering that explains the likelihood of transmission of the virus that causes COVID-19. Other factors, such as not wearing masks and the distance between people, also affect transmission of the virus.
Objectives and Standards
Students will create a model that shows disease transmission in various-sized crowds and use their model to explain how social distancing and avoidance of large gatherings can help slow the spread of certain infectious diseases.
NGSS Science and Engineering Practices
Asking questions and defining problems
Developing and using models
Planning and carrying out investigations
Materials and Setup
Materials for Science Investigation
25 similar small objects (such as marbles, pebbles, or pennies)
2 packages of powdered drink mix
4 clear, similar-size containers (such as plastic food storage, jars with lids, etc.)
2 white paper towels, folded to fit into 2 of the containers
spray bottle filled with plain water
"The More the Merrier Task Card" (student page)
Setup and Teaching Tips
This activity can be conducted as a demonstration by you, the teacher, or by each student, either in the classroom or at home.
Procedure and Extensions
Ask students What is “social distancing”? Accept all answers.
Explain that public health officials advise people to avoid large gatherings. Why do you think it is important to not attend large events during a pandemic? How does limiting the capacity at sports stadiums or movie theaters help slow the spread of certain diseases? Give students time to respond.
Inform students that while we cannot see the virus moving among people, we can use a model to represent disease transmission in different-size crowds.
If you, the teacher, are doing this as a demonstration, proceed with the steps below. If students are conducting this investigation, refer to “The More the Merrier Task Card” student page and review the steps with them.
Empty 1 package of powdered drink mix into a clean, clear container and add in 5 of the small objects (pennies, marbles, and similar-size pebbles work well!). Close the lid and shake the container for 20 seconds.
Carefully remove the lid and use tongs to transfer each object to a clean container lined with a paper towel. Secure the lid to this container and shake for 20 seconds. After shaking, discard the small objects, leaving only the paper towel in the container.
Repeat Step 5 and 6, this time placing 20 small objects into the container with the drink mix.
Use the spray bottle containing water to spray the paper towel in each of the two containers 10 times.
After the demonstration or student investigations, compare the results from the two containers.
Ask the students: What differences do you observe between the two containers? What accounts for the differences observed?
How can this model be used to explain why it is critical to avoid large gatherings during a pandemic?
What further questions do you have that we could test using this same model to answer your questions? Further probe student questions to narrow in on specific variables and what each represents in the model, for example, What would happen if we used less powdered drink mix? Or, What would we expect to happen if we used larger containers or more small objects?
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Considerations for Events and Gatherings. https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/community/large-events/considerations-for-events-gatherings.html
The COVID HACKS curriculum project is made possible thanks to the support from Laura & John Arnold and Baylor College of Medicine. Scientists, educators, and physicians from Baylor College of Medicine provided content, feedback, and technical reviews.